Well Contamination in Fresno County

Groundwater Contamination

Many of us do not think about what is in the water that we drink or where it is sourced, especially in the United States. Unfortunately, clean and safe drinking water is not accessible to all communities and is often the result of the contamination of water sources, like groundwater. Groundwater contamination occurs when chemicals like those used for agriculture, move into the hydrologic system. With the rise of more industrialized agriculture in the 1960s, the use of chemicals has continued to increase to improve crop productivity and control disease and pests. Common contaminants include nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus and pesticides which infiltrate the water system USGS. Additionally, the transition of land into farmland further impairs and disrupts water systems. While certain areas suffer from elevated exposure, this issue is widespread. In a USGS study, researchers found that at least one pesticide was found in about 94 percent of water samples and in more than 90 percent of fish samples taken from streams across the Nation, and in nearly 60 percent of shallow wells sampled Hamilton et al. 2004. This poor groundwater quality can have negative effects on agricultural production, ecosystems, and disadvantaged communities as they lack the financial and technical capacity to manage water quality issues Hanak, 2019.

Fresno County, California

Fresno County is located in one of the most productive agricultural areas in the world. The county alone has nearly 1.9 million acres of farmland and produces more than 300 crops. In 2020, the county was ranked the #1 agricultural county in the U.S. with a gross value of $7.98 billion. Top crops include almonds, grapes, pistachios, tomatoes, oranges, and peaches Visit Fresno County. As a result, the use of pesticides, fertilizers, and other agricultural runoff heightens the risk of contamination via groundwater runoff. Across California, chemicals like per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances are being discovered in well-water and irrigated cropland is the largest source of groundwater nitrate pollution in the Central Valley Dzurella 2015. Effects of contamination include chronic diseases like cancer, gastrointestinal illnesses, and nervous or reproductive system impacts. Simazine, diuron, norflurazon, and bromacil have been detected in well water samples; they have been listed in regulation as known groundwater contaminants, and their use is regulated in vulnerable areas Troiano et al. 2013. Previous studies have established that race/ethnicity and socioeconomic class have previously been correlated with exposure to nitrate and arsenic contamination in community water systems in the San Joaquin Valley where small water systems are more vulnerable to inadequate regulatory protection and to uneven monitoring Balazs 2014.In addition to groundwater pollution, communities in West Fresno also rank as one of the areas most burdened by air pollution in California, and 20 of the most polluted census tracts in Fresno County compose of 89% of people of color in the county Fresno Department of Public Health. Additionally, previous studies in the San Joaquin Valley have shown that among these smaller water systems, community water systems that serve larger percentages of Latinos or home renters experience higher levels of nitrate in their drinking water Balazs 2011. Due to the high agricultural production in the county and the extensive use of pesticides and fertilizers, this project will analyze the relationships between population demographic characteristics and groundwater well contamination to determine if disadvantaged communities are disproportionately affected by the negative effects of groundwater contamination.

Maximum Contaminant Level in Groundwater Wells. Source: CA Small State Water System. Contaminants include NO3N, Uranium, Alpha particles, As, Cb, and lead. Of the 18 wells measured, one well had 4 contaminants above MCL, 1 well had 3 contaminants above MCL, 6 had 1 contaminant above MCL, and 8 did not exceed MCL. Based on these levels, well water quality risk was rated as low, medium, or high. Wells labeled high had at least one contaminant above MCL, and medium contained at least one between 80%-100% MCL.

Map of Groundwater Threat and Well Locations

The western half of Fresno County experiences significant groundwater threats as the majority of census tracts in this region rank in the 60 to 100 Percentile for Groundwater Threat CalEnviroScreen). 4 wells ranked as high risk are located within the 80-100th percentile tracts. Wells in tracts experiencing minimal groundwater threat have low water quality risk.

Map of Poverty Percentile and Well Locations

Census tracts in the 80-100th percentile for Poverty in Fresno County are located in the western half of the county. Indicating that residents in these tracts are exposed to higher contamination in their water. Out of five wells located in these census tracts, four are high water quality risk. In the San Joaquin Valley, 10% of the population is affected by groundwater contamination, disproportionately affecting the poor Brown, 2015). Additionally, Black and Latino residents are most likely to live in high-poverty neighborhoods National Equity Atlas.

Map of Housing Burden and Well Locations

While there are limited census tracts in the county in high percentiles for housing burden, the western half of the county does experience the most variation in percentile. There are still contaminated wells in unburdened areas, and in correlation with other socioeconomic factors, it is not unreasonable to assume that more burdened areas experience more contamination in their water. In these census tracts, Southeast Asian and Latino households are most likely to be cost-burdened among homeowners National Equity Atlas.

Map of Hispanic Population Distribution and Well Locations

The majority of the Hispanic population resides in the western half of the county, with some census tracts over 90% Hispanic. Because the majority of wells located in these tracts have high water quality risk, these residents are exposed to more contaminants in their water compared to other census tracts in the county.

Map of Fresno County Land Use and Well Locations

Top-producing crops in the county are both water-intensive and contribute to groundwater contamination. Additionally, these crops are predominantly located in the western half of the county which contains a high percentage of tracts with lower household income. Due to the topography of the county, the majority of the Eastern half of the county is not agricultural, and agricultural land parcels are predominantly orchards. Comparatively, the majority of the western half of the county is agricultural land parcels which include vineyards, pasture, truck and field crops, and rice. Five wells with high water quality risk are located in close proximity to vineyards. Vineyards require little fertilization and grow deep roots which limit toxins like nitrate from leaching Brown, 2015. As a result, close proximity to truck crops or orchards does not seem to have a large impact on well water quality risk.

Methods

The shapefile of the 2019 crop mapping to map land use within Fresno County was sourced from the California Department of Water Resource. This data was collected using remotely sensed imagery and builds upon Statewide Crop Maps from previous years. I filtered the data to Fresno County and focused on land parcels from rice, pasture, truck crops, field crops, grain and hay, and vineyards. Data used for the socioeconomic analysis for Fresno was sourced from the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment CalEnviroScreen 4.0 statewide shapefile and filtered to Fresno County. Well data was sourced from a State Small Water System Water Risk CSV file from the California Water Resources Control Board. The data was filtered for Fresno County, converted to SF, and then projected to the state plane. The CalEnviroScreen shapefile and State Small Water System Water Risk CSV file were mapped and used to analyze relationships between well proximity and socioeconomic status within the county. The map created using the Statewide Crop Map shapefile and State Small Water System Water Risk CSV file was used to analyze relationships between groundwater contamination and agricultural crop variation.

Conclusion

Although Fresno County is one of the most productive agricultural regions in the world, the mass industrialization of agricultural processes has negative effects on the community and ecosystem. Comparison of well location and proximity to disadvantaged census tracts emphasized the disproportionate effects of groundwater contamination on disadvantaged communities. In addition to high poverty rates and poor health in comparison to the state of California, residents in western Fresno County are exposed to water contaminants including NO3N, Uranium, Alpha particles, As, Cb, and lead above maximum contaminant levels in their groundwater wells. Additionally, proximity to certain crops seems to influence water quality risk due to differing high water demands and variations in agricultural runoff. Ultimately, well contamination is an issue that can not effectively be resolved at the household level; instead, it is up to lawmakers and water resource officials to decide and reform the water system. These results build upon previous research carried out by the state of California’s Water Resources Control Board, in particular the Groundwater Ambient Monitoring and Assessment Program, as well as previous studies that establish a correlation between water system contamination and socioeconomic class. The following recommendations could potentially improve groundwater quality in Fresno County, especially for disadvantaged communities.

Recognition of the small water system groundwater crisis by larger governance groups and collaboration with nonprofit organizations to support rural communities.Propose statewide bills that secure funding for these communities to support water treatment.

Manage pollution and nutrient leaching from agriculture through changes in agricultural practices to reduce further contamination of groundwater and increase water treatment for well systems that are already contaminated.

Improvement of socioeconomic disparities to decrease disproportionate effects of groundwater contamination on the county population.

Works Cited

Balazs, C., Morello-Frosch, R., Hubbard, A., & Ray, I. (2011). Social disparities in nitrate-contaminated drinking water in California’s San Joaquin Valley. Environmental Health Perspectives, 119(9), 1272-1278.

Balazs, C. L., & Ray, I. (2014). The drinking water disparities framework: on the origins and persistence of inequities in exposure. American journal of public health, 104(4), 603-611.

Brown, C. (2017). Mapping agricultural water contamination risk in California’s Central Valley. Yale Environment Review. Retrieved December 8, 2022, from https://environment-review.yale.edu/mapping-agricultural-water-contamination-risk-californias-central-valley-0

Dzurella, K. N., Pettygrove, G. S., Fryjoff-Hung, A., Hollander, A., & Harter, T. (2015). Potential to assess nitrate leaching vulnerability of irrigated cropland. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 70(1), 63-72. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2489/jswc.70.1.63

Esnault, L., Gleeson, T., Wada, Y., Heinke, J., Gerten, D., Flanary, E., … & van Beek, L. P. (2014). Linking groundwater use and stress to specific crops using the groundwater footprint in the Central Valley and High Plains aquifer systems, US. Water Resources Research, 50(6), 4953-4973.

Fresno Department of Public Health. “Fresno County Community Health Needs Assessment.” 2020. https://www.co.fresno.ca.us/home/showpublisheddocument/44681/637273059301000000

Hamilton, P. A., Miller, T. L., & Myers, D. N. (2004). Water quality in the nation’s streams and aquifers: Overview of selected findings, 1991-2001.

Hanak, E., Escriva-Bou, A., Gray, B., Green, S., Harter, T., Jezdimirovic, J., & Seavy, N. (2019). Water and the future of the San Joaquin Valley. Public Policy Institute of California, 100.

Troiano, J., Garretson, C., Dasilva, A., Marade, J., & Barry, T. (2013). Pesticide and nitrate trends in domestic wells where pesticide use is regulated in Fresno and Tulare Counties, California. Journal of environmental quality, 42(6), 1711-1723.

USC Program for Environmental and Regional Equity. (2017).”Advancing Health Equity and Inclusive Growth in Fresno County.” National Equity Atlas. https://nationalequityatlas.org/sites/default/files/FresnoProfile_final.pdf

USGS. Agricultural contaminants active. Agricultural Contaminants | U.S. Geological Survey. https://www.usgs.gov/mission-areas/water-resources/science/agricultural-contaminants#overview

Visit Fresno County - attractions, national parks, restaurants and things to do in the fresno clovis area. navigation arrow. https://www.visitfresnocounty.org/