Every year, roughly 600,000 felons and other convicts are
released back into society from US prison systems having completed lengthy
sentences for their crimes.
Unfortunately, the recidivism rates for
these men and women are extremely high; roughly half are
re-incarcerated within
3 years of release, and the rate is even higher among young adult
males. It's no secret that employment is the key to leading a
comfortable
life, but what traps these men and women
is that employment opportunities available to them are very bleak, usually
limited to manual labor jobs such as construction, home improvement, and warehousing.
It is the warehousing industry in particular that interests me in this case, as
the pay and conditions are notoriously poor. What is a man with a family
supposed to do when his average hourly wage is only $9.00? Unfortunately, the
answer for many is to return to crime. This low-wage lifestyle of warehouse ex-offenders is one
that is ultimately a dead end. Their prospects for improving their lives are
very bleak, yet society tells them that hard work will pay off. They are caught
in jobs that cause chronic pain with little reward and this trickles down into
every aspect of their life; housing, relationships, and eventually their
attitude on life. And the rest of society can't even begin to understand it.
They offer very little help or solutions to these problems, which is only
hurting society as a whole.
Needless to say, warehouse ex-offenders are not a varied
group; most often, those who were incarcerated for misdemeanor charges
do not face the same stigmas as those with felonies and therefore still have
much broader work prospects when released from jail. Those warehouse workers
released from prison, however, are usually stuck in this low-wage
profession because their rap sheet already eliminates many jobs from their list
of options. For instance, anyone with a felony may not hold positions where
there is interaction with children, nor can they perform jobs with much
customer contact. Also restricted are jobs where the employee must handle
significant amounts of money or expensive merchandise. So if you group all
released felons into a type of job where there is: a) little to no customer
interaction, b) no interaction with minors, c) no access to large amounts of
cash or expensive goods, you are putting them into low-wage manual labor jobs
away from the retail sector. Count out many jobs that require more skill such
as construction, and suddenly warehouse positions become among the best
options.
Before any employer hires someone with a rap sheet, they often
conduct background checks which are usually the main barrier to employment that
ex-offenders face. Particularly heinous crimes usually eliminate all job
opportunities, but still there is a definite type of criminal that often is
hired by the warehousing industry. Most ex-cons in the industry were
incarcerated for drug offenses, both selling and using, as well as
property charges, such as destruction of property. Also a small percentage of
workers have past offenses of violence, but it is obvious that these offenders
are not as lucky when it comes to obtaining jobs, even in the warehouse
industry.
Not surprisingly, one of the biggest challenges facing
ex-offenders that work in warehouses is their small paycheck. The average
temp floor worker of most warehouses earns about $9.00 per hour worked
(direct hires average %12.48), which hovers at or near the minimum wage in most
states and cities. Because of this, is it any surprise that most of these
workers have to make do with shabby housing, transportation, and
food? Making ends meet gets even harder considering that many ex-cons have health
issues, leftover fines, and one or more dependents
in their household. Because of this, an estimated 37% of all warehouse workers
need to work a second job to provide a decent lifestyle for their families,
regardless of whether or not they are ex-offenders, meaning that those who are
have it even more difficult, as finding one job is hard enough, let alone
finding a second that allows more flexible hours.
Like many businesses, warehouses are still somewhat cautious
about their ex-offender employees, leading them to often avoid hiring them as
direct hires, and instead more and more are turning to temp agencies to provide
them with labor. These agencies happen to be the same places that many ex-cons
turn to for help finding employment once released, leading to the high number
of ex-offenders being placed in warehousing jobs across the nation. However,
coming as a temp worker means a few things are different than the direct hires.
First and most obvious is the difference in wages, but other conditions
are also different. For instance, temps are almost basically expendable,
often hired by certain warehouses only for a season or two before being let go
and bouncing around to another warehouse.Temporary workers also do not receive worker's compensation
for injuries or have the ability to form a union. What's more, these
workers do not obtain any seniority positions, meaning they can't really move
up in the workplace. Another harmful aspect of being a temporary worker is that
these people are constantly reassigned to various warehouses, making it a
constantly changing work environment with new equipment, procedures, and
coworkers. This makes it very difficult to become comfortable with the
surroundings and people that they work with, leading to a very pessimistic attitude
on the part of temporary ex-offenders in this industry.
One difficulty faced by ex-offenders in warehousing is their
poor housing prospects. This is due in part to their history as well
as their low wages, which create barriers towards getting a nice
place in a safe location, especially one where temptations are not as
common. If they're lucky, they are able to find a place far from their old
neighborhoods, but for most, joining a middle-class housing complex is rare.
Usually they end up only able to afford a disadvantaged neighborhood, where
several problems pile up as a result. First, these neighborhoods can often mean
unsafe and tempting environments for any children that ex-offenders
may need to take care off. Also, they can present a barrier towards forming
solid friendships and relationships with neighbors and potential friends
because the neighborhood is not as open and friendly. Lastly, they continue to
present temptations for crime that some simply can't resist because of their
fragile mental situation; they have bleak employment opportunities, live a
rough lifestyle, and often have multiple other barriers such as past injuries
or fines to pay off.
Many ex-offenders who are newly released need to work
immediately in order to provide for their families and cover housing
and other dues. However, jumping right into the work force -
especially a hard manual labor job such as warehousing - are compounding
problems that will continue to cost them in the future both in terms of money
and discomfort. The problem is that many warehouse workers lack the sufficient
insurance to treat their injuries and illnesses, further debilitating them each
day they work in the poor warehouse conditions. And especially as a temporary
hire without workers' compensation, there is almost no chance to get back to
100%. Because of their low pay, most ex-offenders are
unable to immediately provide themselves with medical attention for the slew of
common illnesses and injuries that they carry with them in their return to
society. In addition, many also face drug addictions that need attention yet
never receive treatment, which is a high indicator of recidivism and return to
crime. According to one study even, 15 percent of people studied claimed to
have debilitating health problems, while another 15 percent could not even work
because of permanent disability. Another 6 percent had to attend treatment
problems when released. Another study from 1997 put up even higher numbers,
with 31% of respondents claiming physical or mental impairment and 25% claimed
to be alcohol dependent.
Low wages make life difficult for everyone involved, but the
stress is increased exponentially with each dependent that a working member of
the family has to support, especially if the man or woman has to make do with
low warehouse wages. According to one study, about 5 percent of those
interviewed did not even work because of having to care for family members, and
56% asked had children under 18. Those that go to work each day and leave their
dependent family at home face immense stress. Most are unable to provide
quality housing in a safe neighborhood and worry that their children
will fall to the same temptations to crime that they did. In
addition, the poor neighborhoods that these families must live in do not
provide the children with good educational opportunities, as the best school
districts are in the higher-income neighborhoods. Other ex-offenders have to continue to provide for sick or
elderly parents, grandparents, or other family members, which cause further
strain on the low income. More worrisome is the inability for these
ex-offenders to provide health assistance for themselves, much less
their family members.
Ex-offenders working in the warehousing industry
face an uphill battle when it comes to staying clean and avoiding becoming just
another recidivism statistic. Unfortunately, for many this battle is too much,
and the combination of low wages, poor housing, and chronic
pain cause many to look toward illegal means for either additional
income or for stress relief. The problem with the whole situation is that the
environments they find themselves in are ones where these outlets are very
readily accessible. Because of the high rate of ex-cons and future cons in the
workplace, those returning to society are constantly plagued by temptation to
make a little extra money on the side or unwind with some drugs after a long difficult
week. The statistics do not lie about the difficulties that
ex-cons face staying on the straight and narrow: one study reports about a 50%
re-incarceration rate within 3 years of release from prison, while about 66%
are at least re-arrested during the same time period. What's more, the rates
are higher for 20-40 year-old men, whose tendency to be re-arrested does not
seem to drop off until they are over the age of 40. Clearly, the solution to this problem has to be found in the
rehabilitation programs. Drug rehab is a key, as some experts estimate that
about 50% of crimes are drug related or indirectly motivated by drugs. Another
key is the employment programs, many of which do not offer education, but
simply place ex-offenders in the nearest warehouse that will take them on as a temp
worker, where the low-wage life traps them. When ex-offenders return to society, they don't often get a
clean fresh start. Many need to begin working immediately to pay off debts, old
tickets, and court and lawyer fees, all of which drain their low warehouse wages. Some can't even obtain their own transportation because
outstanding fines and tickets have resulted in a suspended license. In that
case, their job opportunities are even more limited to the extent of public
transportation.
Most - if not all - ex-offenders in the warehousing industry
hold low-wage entry-level positions, especially if they are temporary
hires. Often, these workers are seen as being completely expendable, not
equal, and only used until no longer needed. This attitude taken on by many
employers and fellow employees means that the margin for error for these kind
of worker is almost nothing. There are hundreds waiting to take any position
that opens up, so employers are not shy at all about firing these men and
women. Because of their past, many ex-offenders come to work each day with
something weighing on their mind; it could be their remaining dues,
their poor families, or their lingering health issues. In
some instances, follow-up legal hearings drag the worker from their job repeatedly,
leading to spotty work attendance. Other times, they are re-arrested for minor
infractions that were too tempting to pass up. Sometimes, the
employee is fired for any minor confrontation at work, because they may have a history
of violence. Ex-offender employees may also struggle adjusting to their new
responsibilities at work, as well as simple things such as being on time for
things. Dealing with these things daily causes numerous slip-ups on their part,
which are not looked upon lightly, but rather solved simply by terminating
them. There is a lower tolerance for these kinds of workers because of their
reputation, their history, and simply their label as temporary workers.
|